Thanks for your replies, everyone!
Terri, you've read my mind because red eyes definitely aren't my things. I've been bouncing between Caramels, Ambers and Honeys on which morph I like best, but I will definitely add Gold Dusts to the list. I'm torn because I love bright yellows, but I also love really distinct saddles (preferably dark-lined, but I'm trying to not be too picky). It seems like individuals of the two and three trait Caramel morphs are less likely to have those distinct saddles, which is why I'm currently leaning towards true Caramels, but again, that's just individual variation for you.
Twolunger, I love VMS! They are a huge part of the reason I developed this corn snake obsession. It's a little hard to truly get a feel for what their hatchlings will turn out like since they only show one example of adult appearance usually. I did try using the Wayback Machine on the Internet Archive to see what the two yearling Caramel girls they have for sale looked like as hatchlings and that was somewhat helpful. I've also looked at Walter Smith's site since he does show the actual parents, which like you said, is only truly helpful if the parents actually have the same phenotype. His site is also part of the reason I asked about variation because he has two clutches where Butters with exact same genotypes are the parents and look like they could be from completely different morphs!
http://www.wscornsnakes.com/clutch-21.html
http://www.wscornsnakes.com/clutch-37.html
Rich, sounds like it might just be the luck of the draw for me, which is fine of course since I'm just looking for a potential pet rather than a breeding snake so I will love whatever I get and not have a fit. Based on my little bit of research I did with VMS and the Wayback Machine, the Caramel babies with yellow spots (the ones between the saddles) going the furthest down their back seem to grow up the brightest. However, like you said, it probably could go either way (plus, you know, you've been at this for decades and I've only been oogling at snakes on my computer for the past few weeks so you probably know WAY better than I do).