Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't Eastern Box Turtles illegal to sell in pet stores? I know they are in Indiana, at least. They're a threatened species here, so that may have something to do with it.
I've hatched quite a few the past few years. Due to living in a forest and all, the female box turtles think my nice soft garden soil and flower beds make great nest sites.
Garden Turtle 1
Garden Turtle 2
Turtle Eggs
I dig the nests up to avoid them getting damaged or pilfered, and incubate them in the same incubator as my cornsnake eggs. Same duration and temp requirements for incubation. I then release them back into the wild after a few meals of supplimented worms and bugs and hope for the best.
While adorable as babies...
Picture 1
Picture 2
Picture 3
Picture 4
They really need an outdoor environment, and if the proper nutrients aren't met they can be disfigured for life. Most of the people who own the wild caughts around here, make a large high-sided outdoor enclosure for them to roam and eat what they need, and suppliment them a diet of healthy greens and fruits.
Plus, most seem to need to hibernate, and will try to sleep through the winter even while indoors. So that's just one more thing to have to worry about.
I can attest to how hard they are to care for properly. And me, while not a beginner to herps by any means...I had a hard enough time managing, so I can't imagine the typical average beginner. I just don't think turtles or tortises are a wise first reptile pet for most young beginners. They're a lifetime committment, imho.