Oh yes, at those temps 4'' is just fine. You wont be using much at all to heat. The big 11'' and 16'' is really for back heat when you are heating the whole RACK through wood not just making a belly heat spot on the tubs. A couple of pointers for building racks:
You can save yourself a lot of wiring and headache if you "snake" your heat tape along the bottom of the shelf, then down the side of the next shelf, then across that shelf, then down etc etc. That way you dont have to wire each individual shelf, plus you get additional "side" heat where the heat tape rests against the edges of the tub. Just make sure you make 4.5'' grooves for the heattape to slide through. the downside is you have to buy a couple more feet of tape.
Remember that unless you have your rack sitting on top of something, the bottom rack will always be a few degrees cooler then your top rack.
If you are only using one thermostat make sure you put the probe outside the tub ontop of the heattape, so you get a good acurate reading of how hot that tape is.
Reptilebasics will cut your heattape to whatever lengths you need AND pre-wire it for you, for free. You just have to ask them, give them the demensions, and buy how ever many wiring kits you need.
REMEMBER TO GET A THERMOSTAT!!!! Heattape is USELESS without a good thermostat.
Since 72 in of itself is just fine for the cool side of their cage, all they need is an additional hotspot so even 3'' would be ok if you wanted to do it!

Corns are so easy!