I HATE the light, washed-out aspen look, but I LOVE the dark, natural, no-smell, easy-scoop characteristics of my bed-a-beast. The only problem I have is that they don't say what they put in it, but I talked to a few people who said it's fine. I'm not sure, but I think I have also heard what xelda said about the similarities, All I need to know is that bed-a-beast is cheap, scoopable, and looks great.