Abcat1993 said:
My dad was about to go to Australia or something a few years ago to see them both together. The albums with Gilmour were too 90ish for me [although I do like High Hopes, One Slip (really 90ish with the drum solo), and Sorrow].
Wait...which albums with Gilmour were too "90's"? Piper at the Gates of Dawn? Gilmour is an original "Floydian", having been there since day one.
Now, I'll grant you that "The Division Bell" was a step away from the 70's psychodelia, but you can't deny that Gilmour influenced every musical movement they ever made from day one. Syd Barrett would have been nothing without David Gilmour to mellow out his psychotic lyrics.
Everything that Gilmour has done with the band since Roger Waters left
still is very reminiscent of the original Pink Floyd, in my ever so humble opinion.
I'd even go so far as to say that Roger Waters would have failed
miserably on both Dark Side of the Moon AND The Wall, had Gilmour not been such a unifying thread throughout both albums. Without Gilmour's voice and guitar technique giving the albums a sense of "grounded in reality" melody, both of those albums would have been too far over the top for even devout Floyd fans, I believe. Waters is almost as far out there as Barrett was, and gilmour keeps them both on track...musically. It is always gilmour as the voice of reason, both musically and voaclly, IMO.
I saw Floyd play at Giant's Stadium during their Division Bell tour. The band was in incredible form, and I didn't miss Roger Waters one bit, though I admit that it would be nice to see a reunion tour show...