Rich Z said:
So judge them I did, and I still could not find any reason to say "Oh, yeah, you are right. You were completely justified to act as you did then."
The sad thing is that you still think this is what people wanted. I guess by "unjudging" I mean the situation should be judged and not the people. However, if the people were to be judged, judge them on a bigger track record than a couple of weeks. The fact is, due to the chat incident, you completely turned off your ears to anything anyone had to say about it and read post after post of people saying "I'm not justifying my actions, but we do need some help with the trolls in chat" and time and time again you interpreted these statements as "I'm just trying to justify my bad behavior".
I made a few posts commenting on how bad the trolls had got, but apparently I was justifying bad behavior too, even though I had nothing to do with that log. Shortly after I left chat, you made sure to post in front of everyone that people left chat because theirr "knickers were in a knot" over being told to act like adults. This left a lot of us out there that had mantained our adult behavior the entire time with a bad label as "throwing a fit because we had to behave lilke adults" no matter what our reasons for leaving chat were.
Rich Z said:
Seriously, some of those people believe that that incident damaged their entire reputation? "1% of inarguably unacceptable behavior wiped out 99% of good citizenship"? Sorry, but no, I just don't see it. So will anyone here chime in if THEY felt that the people engaged in that chat incident lost their reputation because of it? Maybe it's just me, but I certainly don't see it that way at all. And if anyone had reason to be disgusted and consider the perpetrators of that incident in a permanently unflattering light, I thing that would be me. And that certainly is not the case at all.
I don't think they have lost their "cornsnake" reputation, but I think you and a few others here don't realize the impact you have on how people are viewed here. I'd be more than happy to drop this whole matter except for the fact that many of us that made adult decisions are still being called immature and labeled as throwing a fit. The whole reason I started this post was because people are still making unfair representations that others left because they were told to act like adults in chat. I've talked to the majority of people who have left and I know that's not the case. It's the fact that you wouldn't listen to anything anyone had to say about the matter without your prejudgement of "They are just trying to justify the behavior" in mind.
Say you had a loyal friend for many years with a special trade that helped you build your house. Maybe they did the landscaping for a couple of years, maybe they repainted your home when you needed it or maybe did some house cleaning just because they liked you, they liked your family, they liked to be in your home, and they liked to help. Perhaps one day your friend comes over in a rage and punches a couple of holes in the wall. Now of course you are going to be upset and bring an end to it as soon as possible. You are more than likely to have a few choice words with your friend that this behavior is unacceptable in your home and they need to leave until they are under control.
Scenario #1. Any good friend is going eventually want to know what made this person act this way. Going over and giving your distraught friend a listening ear and trying to help them out if possible has NOTHING to do with justifying the holes in the wall. By listening to your friend, you may find something legitimate, you may not. You will definitely never hear anything that will justify the holes in the wall, but if you just listen without name calling or judging the person, likely that person will feel bad, apologize and repair your wall.
Scenario #2. Your friend leaves, cools down and then comes back. Every effort they make to contact you gets a "Nothing you can say will justify the holes in my wall, end of discussion", and any action they take after that you make sure you let everyone know that it must be a decision based on immaturity. You let everyone know that they stopped coming to your home because they were "pissed" they weren't allowed to punch holes in the wall. Even though your friend was sorry, he got tired of being unable to communicate with you and left. You announced that by their leaving, they must be going to a place where this is allowed because boy does this person like to put holes in walls.
Yeah, it is just as I suspected. Some people apparently got their knickers in a knot because I posted this thread in an effort to get the participants to cut out the petty crap I saw taking place in it. So rather than comply, the people this thread was pointed towards decided to just go elsewhere.
I really can't believe that anyone would condone the crap I saw in chat log segments sent to me and get pissed that I asked that it STOP.
People left chat because the trolls were bringing out things in people nobody was proud of, and got the public "Rich Z" judgment above.
Give yourself more credit. When you make accusations like the one above, it hurts people reputations on this site. I left chat. I don't condone the crap we saw in the log. I didn't get pissed that you asked it to stop. I'm sure the majority of people who left agree with those last three sentences. But it's quite apparent that no one will ever convince you of that. It will be the age old tradition on CS.com to dub thee immature fit throwers.
And yet each time I see quotes like this:
If that did, in fact, precipitate those people leaving because of my stance on that issue, then they in fact laid down the rules as my taking their side or they were taking the highway.
I, the glutton for punishment, try to point out that this wasn't the case in anyone I know of.
I donno why I've babbled on this far. I guess it struck a nerve that my name was put in the same post with statements such as "throwing a fit" and "immature". If that's what people want to call it. So be it. But for the rest who want my opinion... When you see someone pulling the rug from under people, you're likely to take one foot off the rug yourself.