Actually, nope. I was using "aner" back when kingsnake.com was still alterna.com, so that should give you a clue how long before Chuck was around that I was using the term......lol. That has nothing to do with anything because "aner" is an abbreviation - NOT a morph name. The errors have nothing to do with the debate over the term "granite," either. That is an ethical debate and not one over facts. All of the errors that bother me are mainly the weakly supported modes of expression that are stated as fact and not as a hypothesis prior to when it is possible for it to be actually known - especially when the stated mode of expression are only possible if some test crosses are ignored - and with morphs being IDed as "insert name here" based on similar appearances before any possible test crosses have confirmed such a statement presented as fact. I believe those are major problems since they mislead people. Minor ones - like giving the wrong person credit for proving out the terrazzo morph (Boyd - not Galewood) and leaving out morphs he knows already exists - aren't going to deleteriously effect snake buyers, so who cares? Leaving out morphs intentionally may not even be a bad idea for someone who needs a reason to get buyers to buy a new copy EVERY year - you know, leave something out so you have someing new next year in your pocket already. It makes sense from a publishing standpoint, so who can blame him. It's smart to do that even if it isn't what some people think of as "right" or "fair." Who cares about "fair" when the goal for any such venture is ultimately profit? Duh.
KJ, how is it an ethics issue about Granite? People came up with the name totally seperate from the original Granites now known as Terrazzo corns? People started using the name and it stuck. Only so many people knew about the original Granite project! But as you said, this isn't about that arguement. And funny people think Chuck is some sort of name god that is responsible for names! He's just posting up information down into a book to share with the masses instead of it being a select few people knowing about things.
http://cornsnakes.com/forums/showthread.php?t=16976
And excuse both of us, I was also at the table when Galewood came by and was talking to Chuck and said HE was the one who proved the Terrazzo corns! So for all Chuck knew, Boyd didn't exist! Chuck talked with Galewood and we both got to take pictures of these corns he had. And so we had our info and pictures, and Chuck put it in print.
And then weakly supported facts of how stuff is expressed? I'd like to know exactly what your referring to, cause all Chuck's putting in his book is easily found and reproduced in any genetics text book? Certainly there are traits that are still needing to be proved out on how they work out. But why be so hesitant to put a label on something. Why not try to get others to speak up about what they are finding in their crosses? That's what is so neat about this publication! It's all written down information that increases year to year as stuff is found out. And stuff that is still up in the air yet is stated as such as far as is known as fact at that point in time. Granted opinions can vary on such things! And everyone is entitled to an opinion! And in book form too!
And this idea you have of him hiding morphs to publish about them next year? Oh come on KJ! Your more intelligent than that! What's the chance he's going to have new morphs created AHEAD every year to publish about them, and tell others, oh hush, we'll not announce this new morph till 2010, and this other one till 2011.... Now that's just pure funny to me! I know you've GOT to be kidding! You act like he's got some sort of conspiracy going on! Like he's some sort of morph mafia king! Using secret tactics, and waving his magic wand... Some of us love Chuck, but come on, he's not THAT good! And does not the first sentence of the CMG clearly state...and I quote... with permission...from page 2 of the CMG
This guide is intended to act as a starting point and a reference, as opposed to an all-encompassing knowledgebase.
So see? it wasn't meant to include EVERY iota known or thought to exist about cornsnake morphs! First sentence! So come on KJ, I have no quarrel with you nor have I ever had to. But this above statement of yours had to be put to the truth that so plainly sits in my lap here plus a big of good old fashion common sense!
Now I'm going to go and have a good read. I'm very thankful someone has taken the time to put down into writing the known info, the suspected info, and the new info that is out there on cornsnake morphs and genetics! All done by himself, book by book. Definetly worth more to me than the pittance he's asking for it! I've enjoyed all his editions. Which do get better every year. I actually was sad to see his genetics section go but I understand with all the info he wanted to put in. It was simply getting too big so he put the genetics info into his other little book he puts out. Plus apparently he put that information for FREE on his website so that information isn't gone, just found elsewhere for those who still need to learn genetics.
http://cornguide.com/geneticspages.php?page=1
Plus I'm very thankful to all the people who cooperated with him on this project. This has NOT been a totally Chuck only book. Not by a long shot! Chuck's only put the info into book form. Information that comes in from all breeders! Pictures that came from many different people! It's a book that sure Chuck's the author of the words, but the information and pictures in that book are totally the hobby itself being put into written form. That experts and beginners alike can get ahold of information and LEARN. Not a, oh a few people knew about this project that is twenty years old and oh, *gasp* how DARE these OTHER people call these OTHER corns the same name? See how NOT having this information in book form allowed that mess to happen?
I'm very thankful to Chuck first and foremost for being willing to put his time in that is NOT paid for, putting this book together and available to people in this hobby. And thankful to everyone else that continues to contribute to the project.
Thank you!